← Back to GSCO dashboard
Documented Migration Cases
Real-world occupational classification mismatches drawn from ministries, statistical offices, peer-reviewed research, and journalism. Each case demonstrates one way that legacy classifiers fail working people. Click each source link to verify directly — we cite, we do not copy.
117 cases across 54 source countries. Companion to our Zenodo paper (Appendix A) — DOI to be assigned at first upload.
UA (12 cases)
Ukrainian Doctors in Germany — Approbation Queue (2022–2024)
Countries: DE · UA
1,674+ Ukrainian doctors applied for Approbation (full medical licence) post-Feb 2022; only 187 authorised to practice by mid-2023; ~1,400 in queue.
Ukrainian Medics in Bulgaria — Language Gate vs. Healthcare Need (2022)
Countries: BG · UA
51 Ukrainian doctors (including professors) + 68 nurses expressed intent to stay and work in Bulgaria post-Feb 2022; Bulgarian Medical Association (БЛС) publicly advocated fast recognition; Bulgaria has chronic nursing shortage.
Source: lexmedicanews.com "БЛС: Ускорена процедура, но без снижаване на изискванията за украинските дипломи" (2022-03-15, BG); darik.bg "Украински медици остават у нас при бързо признаване на дипломите" (BG); zdrave.net "МЗ обмисля улесняване признаването на дипломите на украинските медици" (BG); gpnews.bg …
Hoog opgeleide vluchtelingen (2022–2023)
Countries: NL · UA
~68 000 werkzame Oekraïners (15–65 jaar); 50% aan het werk per mei 2023.
Universitetsutbildade flyktingar (2022–2024)
Countries: SE · UA
~66 000 ukrainska flyktingar mottagna; 56% av arbetsföra hade jobb (2023), 66% år 2024.
Flyktninger på lavkvalifiserte stillinger (2022–2024)
Countries: NO · UA
~77 000 søknader om midlertidig kollektivt vern; fra 3 600 til 65 600 ukrainere i NO (2022→2024).
Højtuddannede som ufaglært arbejdskraft (2022–2024)
Countries: DK · UA
32 000 ukrainske flygtninge i DK; 11 000 i arbejde (feb 2024), 50% beskæftigelsesrate.
Erlent starfsfólk með ofmenntun (2022–2024)
Countries: IS · UA
~5 403 ukraínskir flóttamenn á Íslandi (2024); 2 600 flóttamenn komu 2022, þar af ~1 900 á vinnualdri.
Korkeakoulutetut kielimuurin takana (2022–2024)
Countries: FI · UA
~64 000 tilapäistä suojelua saanutta; ~40 000 on jo lähtenyt Suomesta muihin EU-maihin; 50 000 jäänyt; 40% työllisyysaste (vs.
Arstid ja õed karjääriredeli alumisel astmel (2022)
Countries: EE · UA
Aprillis 2022: 78 õde, 47 arsti, 46 muud spetsialisti Ukrainast otsis tööd Eestis.
Kõrgharidusega töötajad lihttöödel (2022–2024)
Countries: EE · UA
44% tööealistest ukrainlastest (20–64) on tööga hõivatud (2024, kasvav); ~10 600 ukrainlast töötab legaalselt.
Augstizglītoti bēgļi zemkvalificētos darbos (2022–2024)
Countries: LV · UA
~10 600 ukraiņu strādā legāli Latvijā (dec 2024); 26 106 saņēmuši NVA atbalstu.
Specialistai gamyboje ir paslaugose (2022–2024)
Countries: LT · UA
>23 000 ukrainiečių dirba Lietuvoje; 1 866 naujų darbo vietų per Užimtumo tarnybą (jan–maj 2024).
VN (6 cases)
EPS and Filipino/Vietnamese Workers (2015 / updated 2023)
Countries: KR · PH · VN
National-level policy analysis.
Disappearance as Credential-System Exit (2022–2023)
Countries: TW · VN
85,229 "missing" (失聯) migrant workers in Taiwan as of Feb 2024; Vietnamese ~60% of missing.
Structural Bottleneck (2022–2024)
Countries: TW · VN
763,381 total migrant workers in Taiwan (Q1 2024); ~262,957 Vietnamese; only 4.
TITP Skill Mismatch и Рекордное «Бегство» Стажёров (2023)
Countries: JP · VN
~80 000 отправленных в Японию в 2023; рекордные 9 753 исчезнувших (56% — вьетнамцы).
EPS Overstay и Провинциальные Блэклисты (2023)
Countries: KR · VN
>110 000 вьетнамцев по EPS; 23 412 занятых vs плановые 12 000; 8 районов занесены в стоп-лист.
Насилие и Классификационный Вакуум (2020–2024)
Countries: TW · VN
57 611 вьетнамцев — крупнейшая группа нелегальных мигрантов в Тайване (янв.
PL (5 cases)
Ukrainian Doctors in Poland — PWZ Bottleneck (2022–2024)
Countries: PL · UA
~3,930 Ukrainian doctors applied for conditional PWZ (Prawo Wykonywania Zawodu) post-Feb 2022; only ~300 actually employed in Polish healthcare by late 2023 despite approvals; 174 applications rejected.
Ukrainian Nurses in Poland — EU Training-Hours Mismatch (2022–2024)
Countries: PL · UA
1,978 conditional PWZ decisions issued to Ukrainian nurses/midwives post-Feb 2022 (77 limited-scope + 1,901 conditional); ~500 applications still pending at Ministry of Health at peak; Polish system needs 100,000 additional nurses.
Ukrainian Refugees in Poland — Systemic Overqualification (2022–2023)
Countries: PL · UA
~1.
Polish Workers in UK — Mass Overqualification (2004–2019)
Countries: GB · PL · UK
~900,000 Polish workers in UK at peak (2014–2020); Ośrodek Badań nad Migracjami UW (Centre for Migration Research, Warsaw University): 30% of Poles in UK in low-qualification jobs; 40% in medium-qualification jobs; ~50% of Polish university graduates work below their skill level.
Polish Nurses in UK — NMC IELTS Shock (2016)
Countries: GB · PL · UK
Poles ranked 5th among nationalities in NHS; thousands of NMC-registered Polish nurses affected.
Source: pielegniarki.info.pl "Ogólnopolska Gazeta Pielęgniarek i Położnych nr 1/2016 — Nowe zasady uznawania kwalifikacji pielęgniarki w Anglii" (2016, PL); pielegniarki.info.pl "Nowe wieści z NMC — regulacje dotyczące kontroli znajomości j. angielskiego" (2015-12, PL); pielegniarki.info.pl "NMC potwierdził…
RU (5 cases)
IT-специалисты и творческие профессии (2022–2025)
Countries: GE · RU
>62 000 российских эмигрантов прибыло в Грузию в 2022 году, >52 500 в 2023; из них постоянно остаётся ~25 000–30 000 в Тбилиси/Батуми.
IT и не-IT после мобилизации (сент 2022–2023)
Countries: AM · RU
~110 000 россиян переехали в Армению в 2022 году; Ереван стал центром IT-релокаций (66% ищущих работу нацелились на IT в AM/GE).
Смешанный профессиональный состав (2022–2023)
Countries: RU · TR
Турция — ключевой транзитный хаб; сотни тысяч через Стамбул; крупнейший ИТ-диаспорный узел после GE/AM.
IT-репатрианты и non-Jewish (2022)
Countries: IL · RU
~15 000 россиян въехали в Израиль в начале 2022; программа "зелёного коридора" для IT без требования еврейского происхождения.
Синие и белые воротнички после мобилизации (сент 2022)
Countries: KZ · RU
406 000 россиян въехали в Казахстан в сентябре 2022; >36 000 получили РВП до конца 2022.
BG (4 cases)
Eastern European Electricians in Germany — Regulated vs. Unregulated Paradox (2015–2024)
Countries: BG · DE · PL · RO
Hundreds of thousands of Romanian, Polish, Bulgarian tradespeople in Germany.
Source: EU-Gleichbehandlungsstelle.de "Recognition of Foreign Professional Qualifications" (2024); personal-aus-osteuropa.de "Electrician: Recognition of certification of foreign qualifications" (2025); Global-business-recruiting.de "Professional recognition of electricians from abroad in Germany"
Roma Workers Across EU — Credential Absence and Compound Exclusion (2016–2024)
Countries: BG · CZ · ES · HU · RO · SK
6–12 million Roma in EU.
Source: ERRC "Systemic Exclusion of Roma from Employment"; ERGO Network "Roma access to decent and sustainable employment" (2024); IZA World of Labor "Roma integration in European labor markets"; CEDEFOP "Acceder Programme for employment of Roma"
Bulgarian Nurses in Germany — "Feldscherin" Phantom Category (2015–2024)
Countries: BG · DE
Bulgaria among top-5 source countries for nursing recognitions in Germany.
Bulgarian Doctors in UK — Mass Outflow, Diploma Recognition Paradox (2023–2024)
Countries: BG · GB · UK
2023: 435 of 622 doctors (70%) who joined UK workforce in one year graduated from Bulgarian medical schools.
AU (3 cases)
Filipino Nurses in Australia — Excluded from Fast-Track (2025)
Countries: AU · IN · NP · PH
Philippines is one of top 3 source countries for internationally qualified nurses (IQNs) in Australia, alongside India and Nepal.
Source: Filipino Inquirer "Filipino nurses and Australia's new policy" (2024); NEAC Medical Exams "IQRN General Registration New NMBA Standard" (2025); Sable International "How to become a registered nurse in Australia: Tips for Filipino nurses"
Foreign Engineers in Australia — ANZSCO 233999 "NEC" Trap (2016–2024)
Countries: AU
Australia receives ~25,000 skilled engineering visa applications annually.
Source: CDRReportWriter "Engineering Professionals NEC (ANZSCO 233999): Your Australian/NZ Migration Solution"; Engineers Australia Migration Skills Assessment portal; CDRWritersAustralia "Skilled Occupation List 2024"
Foreign Pharmacists — Systematic Multi-Year Waiting Periods (2016–2024)
Countries: AU · GB
UK OSPAP programme: 1-year university + 52-week training before GPhC registration.
Source: Pharmacist Support UK "Overseas Pharmacists' Assessment Programme"; Australian Pharmacy Council response to Home Affairs (homeaffairs.gov.au); PMC "Experiences of migrant pharmacists: phenomenographical study" (PMC10692705, 2023); PharmacistMigration.com guides
BD (3 cases)
Nepali & Bangladeshi Workers Qatar — Systematic Job Substitution (2018–2023)
Countries: BD · NP · QA
~1.
Source: Business & Human Rights Centre "After the Final Whistle" (2023); HRW "Qatar: Six Months Post-World Cup" (2023); Amnesty International Qatar reports (2019, 2023); NPR "Building Qatar's World Cup stadiums" (2022)
Bangladeshi Women Recruited as Domestic Workers (2016–2023)
Countries: BD · SA
Bangladeshi Migrant Domestic Workers, Gendered Credential Erasure (2020–2024)
Countries: BD · LB
DE (3 cases)
Non-EU Doctors in Germany — Approbation Bottleneck (2015–2024)
Countries: DE
~64,000 foreign-licensed doctors working in Germany as of 2024.
Source: Hessenschau "Nachtwache statt Notaufnahme" (2024); Apotheken Umschau "Ausländische Ärzte im deutschen Behörden-Stau"; Arzt-Wirtschaft "Bundestag vereinfacht Verfahren" (2024); Medinside.ch "Deutschland beschleunigt Anerkennung" (2026)
Romanian Doctors — Mass Emigration and Overqualification in Southern EU (2007–2024)
Countries: DE · ES · FR · IT · RO
Between 2014–2017: 3,737 Romanian doctors emigrated; 2018–2021: 2,493 emigrated.
Italian Doctors and Skilled Professionals Emigrating to Germany — "Berufserlaubnis" Limbo and 50% Salary Gap (2008–2024)
Countries: DE · IT
1,637 Italian physicians without German citizenship working in Germany (end 2022, Bundesärztekammer/BÄK data).
HU (3 cases)
Lege/sykepleier (2014–2023)
Countries: HU · NO
Ungarn er blant topp-bidragsytere av utenlandske helsearbeidere til Norge; 58–67% økning i utenlandsutdannede leger/sykepleiere i regionen (2014–2023).
Orvosok és ápolók elvándorlása (2004–2023)
Countries: AT · HU
121 000 magyar dolgozik Ausztriában (2023, összes); egészségügy a 4.
Ápolók bérkülönbség (2022–2023)
Countries: AT · HU
Tízszer annyi szakember hagyja el Magyarországot, mint ahány érkezik; 444.
IN (3 cases)
Indian Healthcare Workers in Care Sector (2022–2023)
Countries: GB · IN · UK
Indian IT/Engineering Immigrants, Overqualification (2021–2024)
Countries: CA · IN
Indian Graduates, Overqualification and Occupation Mismatch (2022–2024)
Countries: AU · IN
IR (3 cases)
Iranian Physicians (2013–2024)
Countries: DE · IR
Iranian Professionals Post-2022 (2022–2024)
Countries: IR · TR
Iranian Engineers & IT Professionals (2022–2024)
Countries: CA · GB · IR
MN (3 cases)
Heavy Industry Workers (2023–2024)
Countries: KR · MN
~55,802 Mongolians in South Korea (2024); est.
Low-Skilled Return Migrants / Skill Atrophy (2021)
Countries: KR · MN
Survey of returning Mongolian EPS workers.
E-7 Visa Occupation Mismatch (2023–2024)
Countries: KR · MN
Systemic (all E-7 applicants from Mongolia).
WB (3 cases)
Serbian/Bosnian Nurses in Germany — Yugoslav Educational System Mismatch (2016–2021)
Countries: BA · DE · RS · WB
Bosnia and Herzegovina ranked #1 source country for nursing recognitions in Germany: 1,940 approvals in 2018, 2,300 in 2019; Serbia #2 in 2018 (1,410).
Croatian/Serbian Engineers in Germany — Short-Cycle Degree Rejection (2016–2020)
Countries: DE · HR · PL · RS · WB
Croatian engineer recognition applications 2016–2020: ~15% rejection rate; Serbian engineers ~16% rejection rate — highest among European origin countries tracked.
Serbian/Bosnian/Macedonian Nurses in Austria — Three-Tier System Gap (2019–2024)
Countries: AT · BA · MK · RS · WB
Austria receives significant nursing workforce from former Yugoslavia.
BR (2 cases)
Brazilian Doctors in Portugal — 57.8% Failure Rate on Ordem Médicos Licensing (2019–2024)
Countries: BR · PT
~1,674 foreign medical degree applications submitted to Portugal's Ordem dos Médicos (2019–2021); Brazilians comprised 74.
Brazilian Engineers in Portugal — 8,000+ Under Reciprocity Agreement but "Engenheiro Sénior" Gap (2015–2025)
Countries: BR · PT
~8,000 Brazilian engineers registered in Portugal under CONFEA-OEP reciprocity agreement (2015); ~5,000 have applied; 4,039 approvals, 3,267 currently active (February 2023).
CA (2 cases)
Foreign-Trained Doctors in Canada — 36% Actually Working in Field (2019–2024)
Countries: CA
Canada.
Source: C.D. Howe Institute "Harnessing Immigrant Talent" (2024); ESDC "Evaluation of Foreign Credential Recognition Program" (2025, Canada.ca); MPI "Credential Recognition in the United States for Foreign Professionals"; InfoMigrants "Brain waste: immigrants overqualified" (2024)
Foreign-Trained Teachers in Canada & USA — Certification Fragmentation (2016–2024)
Countries: CA · FR · US
Canada: persistent shortage of French immersion, STEM, Special Education teachers.
Source: Borgen Project "Reality of Immigrant Credential Recognition in Canada" (2021); Canadian Parliament Library "Recognition of Foreign Qualifications of Immigrants" (2020); California CTC "Teaching in California — Prepared Outside the United States"; Canada.ca "Foreign Credential Recognition" programme
CN (2 cases)
Non-Recognition of Overseas Qualifications (2022–2023)
Countries: AU · CN
23% of all permanent skilled migrants experience skills mismatch (2022 study); 52% feel overqualified; 43% work outside their nominated occupation.
Deskilling of Racialized Skilled Immigrants in British Columbia (2022–2024)
Countries: CA · CN · GB
Mixed-methods study; quantitative n=111, focus groups n=18; Lower Mainland BC; 24.
CO (2 cases)
Venezuelan "Médicos Integrales Comunitarios" Refused — Peru & Colombia (2018–2023)
Countries: CO · PE · VE
~50,000 MIC-trained doctors in Venezuela; 24,819 graduated from PNF-MIC programme including 1,336 foreigners (Colombians, Peruvians).
Source: ElEstimulo.com "Colegio de Médicos de Perú no acreditará a MIC" (2018); ColombiaCheck "Qué son los médicos integrales comunitarios" (2023); Infobae Colombia "Alerta por médicos integrales comunitarios" (2023); CronkiteNews "Venezuelan doctors face difficult recredentialing in Peru" (2019)
Venezuelan Professionals in Colombia — 82% Informal, 18% in Field (2018–2023)
Countries: CO · VE
~2.
Source: R4V "Mercado Laboral Población Extranjera Venezolana en Colombia 2024"; IOM lac.iom.int "82% informal employment" (2023); Banco de la República working paper on Venezuelan labor market; Scielo "Retos y limitaciones migrantes venezolanos Boyacá" (2024)
GB (2 cases)
ICT/Tech Workers — SOC Code Mismatches Causing UK Visa Refusals (2024)
Countries: GB
UK Skilled Worker visa: since April 2024 all applications must use SOC 2020 codes (migration from SOC 2010).
Source: DavidsonMorris "UK SOC Codes – Find the Right Job Code for Your Visa 2026"; AYJ Solicitors "SOC Codes UK: Complete 2026 Guide"; GOV.UK "Skilled Worker visa: eligible occupations and codes"
Italian Professionals in UK Post-Brexit — Mutual Recognition Ended, EU Automatic System Lost (2021–2024)
Countries: GB · IT
~700,000 Italians in UK (pre-Brexit estimate; Il Fatto Quotidiano 2023 notes actual figure 3x higher than Istat official counts).
HK (2 cases)
Systemic Qualification Mismatch (2022–2023)
Countries: GB · HK · UK
180,000+ Hong Kongers arrived in UK since 2021; survey of ~2,000 working-age BNO holders (British Future / Welcoming Committee for Hong Kongers, 2023).
University of Birmingham Employment Survey (2022–2023)
Countries: GB · HK · UK
Detailed survey of HK immigrants' job quality.
ID (2 cases)
EPS Structural Deskilling (2022–2024)
Countries: ID · KR
~303,000 E-9 visa holders in South Korea (2024); ~20% hold university degrees.
Морatorий, Снятие Запрета и Nurse-to-Maid Pipeline (2015–2025)
Countries: ID · SA
~400 000 планируемых домашних работников; ~200 000 формального сектора после снятия моратория.
JP (2 cases)
Filipino Nurses in Japan — 14% Pass Rate on Licensure Exam (2009–2024)
Countries: JP · PH
Japan-Philippines Economic Partnership Agreement (JPEPA, 2008) opened pathway for Filipino nurses and caregivers to work in Japan.
Source: DOLE ILS "Filipino domestic workers in HK and Dubai have opportunities for occupational mobility" (with Japan reference); The Lancet "A long overdue recognition: domestic workers as caregivers in Asia" (2023); NCSBN "Licensure of Internationally Educated Nurses" manual
De-Facto Non-Skilled Classification Despite Heritage (1990–2024)
Countries: JP
211,840 Brazilians in Japan (2023); peak 320,000 (2008).
KH (2 cases)
Cambodian/CLM Workers in Thailand — Confined to Elementary Occupations (2016–2024)
Countries: KH · LA · MM · TH
1–2 million Cambodian, Lao, Myanmar (CLM) workers in Thailand.
Source: ADB "Narrowing Skills Gaps: Labor Mobility from Cambodia, Lao PDR, Myanmar to Thailand" (2025); Winrock/USAID "Prohibited Jobs List" (2022); ADB "Education-Occupation Mismatch Thailand" (2021)
Принудительный Труд и Отсутствие Классификации (2022–2023)
Countries: KH · TH
~459 863 зарегистрированных на янв.
MM (2 cases)
Burmese/Myanmar Professionals in Thailand — Pink Card Misclassification (2021–2024)
Countries: MM · TH
~3–4 million Myanmar migrants in Thailand; 100,000+ politically motivated (post-2021 coup) including former teachers, doctors, university professors.
Source: CMU School of Public Policy "Misclassified and Unprotected: Survival Migration from Myanmar" (2024); Equal Times "Considered neither refugees nor economic migrants, Burmese workers in Thailand eke out a living in the shadows"; IOM Thailand Labour Migration Profile (2025)
Профессионалы Переклассифицированы в Неквалифицированных Рабочих (2021–2024)
Countries: MM · TH
~2.
MX (2 cases)
Mexican Nurses in USA — CGFNS/SEP Bureaucratic Deadlock and NCLEX System Divergence (2020–2024)
Countries: MX · US
Healthcare professionals (nurses + physicians) represent 27.
Mexican Physicians in USA — TN Visa Clinical Restriction Creates Structural Non-Equivalence (2003–2024)
Countries: MX · US
Engineering + healthcare = 70% of all Mexican TN visa holders.
NP (2 cases)
Nepali Workers, EPS Occupational Lock-In (2023)
Countries: KR · NP
Nepali Engineers, Skills Assessment Barrier (2022–2024)
Countries: AU · NP
PH (2 cases)
Elementary Occupation Trap for College-Educated Workers (2022–2023)
Countries: GL · PH
~1.
Pilot Programme for Filipino Domestic Workers Stalled (2024–2025)
Countries: KR · PH
~100 работников (пилот); >3 млн корейских домохозяйств потенциального спроса.
PK (2 cases)
Pakistani Engineers Classified as Unskilled Workers (2021–2024)
Countries: PK · SA
Pakistani Medical Trainees, MTI Fellowship Exploitation (2009–2024)
Countries: GB · PK · UK
TH (2 cases)
Agricultural Workers Caught in War Zone (2023)
Countries: IL · TH
~30 000 тайцев до 7 октября 2023; 34–46 убитых, 22–31 захваченных в плен.
Recruitment Debt & Employer Lock-in (2022–2023)
Countries: TH · TW
TW — 60 191 тайских работников (2023); KR — 17 257 (EPS, 2023).
TR (2 cases)
Turkish Gastarbeiter, Structural Deskilling (1961–1975)
Countries: DE · TR
Turkish Qualification Recognition Backlog (2022–2024)
Countries: DE · TR
TW (2 cases)
Mandatory Re-Licensing via NCLEX-RN (ongoing)
Countries: TW · US
Hundreds per year; CGFNS tracks Taiwan specifically as a sending country.
Taiwanese Physicians as International Medical Graduates (IMGs) (2022–2023)
Countries: TW · US
Non-US citizen IMGs (including Taiwanese): 59.
US (2 cases)
Immigrant Health Workers in USA — 270,000 Underutilised During COVID (2020–2022)
Countries: US
~270,000 immigrants with college degree in medical/health sciences underemployed or unemployed during COVID-19 in USA.
Source: American Immigration Council "Untapped Talent: Costs of Brain Waste" (2021); Baker Institute "Understanding the Role of Immigrants in US Health Sector" (2022); Niskanen Center "Unlocking Potential" (2023); MPI "Immigrant Health-Care Workers in US 2021"
Foreign Lawyers in USA — Jurisdiction Fragmentation (2015–2024)
Countries: US
Thousands of international lawyers annually.
Source: University of Dayton "How International Lawyers Qualify for US Bar"; NCBE "Testing Foreign-Trained Applicants"; BCGSearch "Foreign LL.M. Bar Exam Eligibility" (2024); Temple Law Comprehensive Guide to Bar Admission Requirements
ZK (2 cases)
Zainichi Korean Lawyers Excluded from Court Mediator Roles (2003–2024)
Countries: JP · KR · ZK
31 rejected nominations (2003–2014); at least 14 rejections confirmed by LAZAK.
Nationality Clause in Local Civil Service Bars Promotions (ongoing, documented 2022–2023)
Countries: JP · ZK
~440,000 Koreans in Japan (Special Permanent Residents + regular); all affected.
— (2 cases)
West African Workers — ECOWAS Collapse and New Barriers (2025)
Hundreds of thousands of Burkinabe, Malian, Nigerien workers in Côte d'Ivoire.
Source: Anywr-Group "Burkina Faso, Niger and Mali Standing out from ECOWAS" (2025); IOM "Survey on Migration Policies in West Africa" (2018 — framework still relevant); ECOWAS Wikipedia timeline
Haitian Professionals in Dominican Republic — Structural Exclusion (2010–2024)
~700,000 Haitians in Dominican Republic as of 2018 (MPI).
Source: MPI "Haitian Immigrants in the United States 2018" (background on diaspora); CS Monitor "Unauthorized Haitians Build the Dominican Republic" (2025); NYRB "Between Hate, Hope, and Help: Haitians in the Dominican Republic" (2018)
AE (1 cases)
Indian & Pakistani Engineers in Gulf — "General Worker" Downgrade (2015–2024)
Countries: AE · IN · KW · PK · QA · SA
~3 million Indian nationals + ~1.
Source: ArabNews "Saudi Professional Accreditation Program" (2024); SCE Professional Accreditation page; Saudi Iqama requirements; GCC migrant workers Wikipedia overview
AO (1 cases)
PALOP Workers in Portugal — 39% with Higher Education Below Qualification; Angola 3.4% Medical Pass Rate (2017–2024)
Countries: AO · CV · MZ · PT
~160,000 African residents in Portugal, majority PALOP (Angola, Mozambique, Cabo Verde, Guiné-Bissau).
AS (1 cases)
Нулевая Мобильность
Countries: AS
8 подписантов MRA; 7 МРА по 8 профессиям (сестринское дело, архитектура, инжиниринг, бухгалтерия, стоматология, медицина, геодезия).
AZ (1 cases)
Kazakhstani/Azerbaijani Workers in Russia (2022–2024)
Countries: AZ · RU
BE (1 cases)
African Nurses in EU — Deskilling and Back-to-Square-One (2015–2024)
Countries: BE · FR · GB · GH · IN · NG · NL · PH · SN
"African nurses on the move" scoping review (PMC11929199, 2024) covers Nigeria, Ghana, Senegal, Cameroon → UK, France, Belgium, Netherlands.
Source: PMC "African nurses on the move: scoping review" (2024, PMC11929199); PMC "Experiences of EU and non-EU IENs in UK" (2025, PMC12673689); UNESCO GEM Report "Brain waste: 1 in 8 immigrants in Europe" (2022)
BY (1 cases)
Belarusian IT Workers in Poland — "Cables Before Interviews" (2020–2023)
Countries: BY · PL
Poland Business Harbour (PBH) programme launched Sept 2020 targeting Belarusian ICT sector after disputed election; 55,000 visas issued; ~14,000 by July 2021; ~20,000 IT professionals relocated to Poland by end 2021; programme suspended Jan 2024 over visa-abuse concerns.
CL (1 cases)
Venezuelan Doctors in Chile — EUNACOM Barrier (2017–2024)
Countries: CL · VE
Waves of Venezuelan doctors in Chile; 96% of Chilean graduates pass EUNACOM vs.
Source: D+C Development+Cooperation "Chile's health system attracts foreign doctors, many can't find jobs"; Universidad de Chile revalidation portal; VenezolanenSantiago blog "Trabajar como médico en Chile"; RDUSS.cl "Revisión proceso reconocimiento médicos" (2022)
CU (1 cases)
Cuban Doctors in Spain — Bureaucratic Limbo 2–4 Years (2017–2025)
Countries: CU · ES
Hundreds of Cuban doctors per year arriving in Spain; cases documented of 2–4 year waits before practicing.
Source: CubaHeadlines "Cuban Doctor in Spain Returns to Medical Practice After Four-Year Hiatus" (2025); TranslatingCuba.com "Foreign Doctors Including Cubans Ask Spain for Recognition" (2023); CiberCuba "Cubanos celebran titulos validados" (2025)
CZ (1 cases)
Ukrainian Professionals in Czech Republic — "Scraping Carrots" (2022–2023)
Countries: CZ · UA
473,000 Ukrainians with temporary protection in CZ by end 2022; 75%+ employed in least-skilled jobs (ISCO group 9) despite majority having higher qualifications; 68% of women who were previously managers/professionals work below qualifications.
DZ (1 cases)
Moroccan/North African Engineers in France — Standards Gap (2016–2024)
Countries: DZ · FR · MA
Algeria sends largest non-EU migrant group to France; Morocco second.
Source: Quora "Why is it difficult for African qualified engineers to get a job in Europe?" (practitioner testimony); GFMD Business Mechanism "Challenges and Opportunities of Business Immigration in Maghreb Region" (2020); France-Education-International "Reconnaissance de diplômes" portal
FI (1 cases)
Somali Refugees in Finland — <10% Tertiary Credential Recognition (2015–2023)
Countries: FI · RU · SO
~20,000 Somalis in Finland, majority refugees.
Source: Finnish National Agency for Education recognition statistics; UNESCO GEM Report 2022; CEPR VoxEU "Skilled but struggling: brain waste dilemma of migrants in Europe" (2023); Forced Migration Review "Work and refugee integration in Sweden"
FR (1 cases)
PADHUE — Non-EU Doctors in French Hospitals (2010–2024)
Countries: FR
~5,000+ "practitioners with non-EU diplomas" (PADHUE) working in French hospitals in precarious status; 2,700 of ~4,000 EVC exam candidates rejected in 2023 alone.
Source: StreetPress.fr "Les Padhue, ces milliers de médecins étrangers précaires" (2024); Europe1 "Plus de 3.800 médecins à diplôme étranger admis en 2024" (2024); Sénat question 2024/021049S; ARS Nouvelle-Aquitaine PADHUE guide
IT (1 cases)
Romanian Nurses in Italy — Pre-Accession Training Gap, EU Infringement 2025 (2007–2025)
Countries: IT · RO
Italy hosts 11,861 Romanian emigrant nurses — over 50% of all Romanian nurses working in WHO/Europe countries (2021 data, WHO/Eurostat joint questionnaire).
KG (1 cases)
Kyrgyz Migrants, Occupational Reclassification (2023–2024)
Countries: KG · RU
LA (1 cases)
Trapped in Elementary Occupations (2023–2024)
Countries: LA · TH
~280 000 задокументированных (сент.
MY (1 cases)
74% Мигрантов Квалифицированы, Но Система не Признаёт Их (2022–2024)
Countries: GB · MY · SG
1.
NL (1 cases)
Agrarisch ondernemer (2022–2023)
Countries: CA · NL
~20% van alle NL boeren en tuinders overwoog emigratie (ca.
NO (1 cases)
Eritrean Refugees in Sweden/Norway — Education Not Recognised (2015–2024)
Countries: NO · SE
Eritreans largest non-European asylum group in Sweden (21% of 2014 applicants).
Source: Swedish UHR "Eritrean Secondary Education Certificate (ESEC)"; DIVA-portal Stockholm University demography study (2015); Forced Migration Review "Work and refugee integration in Sweden"; UNESCO GEM Report (2022) Somali Finland <10% statistic
PE (1 cases)
Venezuelan Professionals in Peru — Three-Step Recredentialing (2018–2024)
Countries: PE · VE
~1.
Source: Cronkite News "Venezuelan doctors, nurses face difficult recredentialing process in Peru" (2019); Refugee Law Initiative Blog (2025); ElEstimulo "Colegio de Médicos no acreditará MIC" (2018)
UZ (1 cases)
Uzbek Migrants, Education-Occupation Gap (2022–2024)
Countries: RU · UZ
ZA (1 cases)
Geskoolde migrante (1994–2023)
Countries: GB · UK · ZA
~250 000 Suid-Afrikaners in VK; ~200 000 in Australie; 128 000+ emigreer permanente (2015–2020) — 3× meer as vorige 5-jaar; 67% van ZA-emigrante in Australie het tersiêre kwalifikasies.